Coach Laurie Updike’s Mustangs were 46-2-2 overall the two seasons and 16-2-2 in league play. They outscored opponents 234-33 and posted 27 shutouts.
 

The 2003 team was led by two first-team all-state juniors, forward Jenna Farneti (state Class B Tournament MVP) and midfielder Jocie Jankowski. Updike was named state Class B Coach of the Year.
 

The 2004 team was a more senior-laden squad, led by a trio of first-team all-state seniors:, Farneti (the state player of the year) Jankowski and forward Amy Ware.

Six players from the two teams played collegiately: Candy Hofmann (Syracuse), Farneti (Duquesne), Jankowski (Nazareth/Le Moyne), Alyssa MacLachlan (St. John Fisher), Ware (SU) and Katie Zimmerman (Lynchburg).